May 20th 2008 1:00PM by Tom Mantzouranis (author feed)
Filed under: Saints, NFC South, New Orleans
Astute Saints fans weren’t counting on Dan Morgan to start at weakside linebacker, or even be on the opening day roster. And now that we know his five-plus concussions haven’t inhibited him from making the smart choice about retirement, those of us are vindicated. It’s also clear to everyone now that the Saints haven’t upgraded that spot in the front seven at all, and that’s the fault of a flawed Saints philosophy.
The team hasn’t had a good set of linebackers since the early ’90s. The best linebacker they’ve had since, Jonathan Vilma, hasn’t even gone through a day of training camp. In the past, bad linebacking could be attributed to bad drafting, but Sean Payton has gone in the opposite direction.
In over two years since Payton has taken over, he’s preferred veteran, unspectacular linebackers at the expense sometimes of age, health, and ability. Vilma and, arguably, Scott Fujita are exceptions. But aside from those two, we’ve seen Scott Shanle, Mark Simoneau, Brian Simmons, Anthony Simmons, Dhani Jones, and now Morgan brought in with decidedly average results, if any at all — Jones didn’t last a preseason, and Anthony Simmons retired in the offseason just as Morgan has. Even Vilma, with his knee, is a gamble.
Which means you’ll see Shanle and Simoneau fight for the weakside job, with maybe another listless vet thrown in for “competition.” But for once at this position the Saints should target upside — perhaps a deal with Dallas for Bobby Carpenter, the former first-rounder who seems lost outside of his native 4-3. The team has gambled on plenty of linebackers lately, this is just a different sort of gamble.
